Are The Wheels Starting To Come Off?

geothumbnail10
Chances are, if you are a casual fan of the Verizon IndyCar Series, you may have no idea who George Klotz is. Even if you are pretty much of a die-hard, you may have heard the name but have trouble remembering who he is. No, he is not the eighteenth-century German violin maker. For the past decade, George Klotz has been serving as Team Manager for Andretti Autosport. Klotz has been the one in the background, quietly overseeing four championships among four different drivers at Michael Andretti’s team since joining Andretti in 2002.

That’s why I found it somewhat curious that George Klotz had chosen to leave Andretti Autosport for the not-so-greener pastures at AJ Foyt’s team. No disrespect is meant to the team that the great AJ Foyt started and his son Larry Foyt is trying to rebuild and maintain, but Michael Andretti’s team last won a title in 2012. AJ Foyt’s team hasn’t won a championship since 1979. Many readers of this site had not even been born then. That’s why I find this a curious move.

Although this is considered a lateral move, many would call this moving down the corporate ladder. But there is no indication that this move was initiated by anyone other than Klotz himself. Translation: It sounds like he was not fired.

I am normally not a conspiracy theorist. I believe that Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone in killing President Kennedy. I fully believe that man walked on the moon in July of 1969 and I do not subscribe to the theory that the Twin Towers fell at the hands of the US. I tend to take things at face-value.

That side of me wants to believe that George Klotz chooses to finish his career at the same team where he started as a mechanic in the early nineties – AJ Foyt Racing. Perhaps he no longer wanted to deal with the pressure of developing and massaging the Honda aero kit and squeezing every tenth of a second out of his cars, while serving in such a role at a high-profile team. But if I was looking to avoid pressure, serving under AJ Foyt is not where I would look to go. Even though AJ’s age and health have kept him away from the track for a good portion of each recent season – don’t think for a minute that he’s not following every move. And don’t forget, AJ still makes snap decisions that are seldom questioned.

The National Enquirer side of me has heard whispers and rumors for the last few months that all is not well at Andretti Autosport. Not only are there rumors of discontent among team-members, but lately there have been murmurs that the balance sheet is not so healthy either. These rumors first started surfacing when there was litigation between NOLA Motorsports Park and Andretti Sports Marketing (ASM). They intensified when ASM founders John Lopes and Starke Taylor sued Andretti Autosport and Michael Andretti for removing Lopes as President of ASM. An Andretti company suing an Andretti company is bound to get ugly and it did. Reports surfaced that Michael Andretti had used funds intended for ASM to cover expenses for the race team.

Fortunately, the suit was settled out of court before too much family laundry was aired for the public. Still, the damage to the lofty reputation of Michael Andretti as a savvy businessman was done. In the court of public opinion – perception is reality.

Since then, the rumor-mill has been running at full-capacity. Social media, message boards and even comments on this site have alluded to the notion that Andretti Autosport is in deep financial trouble and that the wheels are about to come off. In fairness, I have heard no credible source even question the financial health of Andretti Autosport. But in this internet age we live in, all you need for a good rumor to take off is to start one on social media and watch it spread.

Not all have seen or heard these rumors. Those that haven’t will accuse me of helping to spread the rumors. Believe me, the rumors are out there and this site does not have the power to spread or silence them. But to fully ignore them would be like ignoring the fact that the Honda aero kit was slower than the Chevy in 2015. It would just be glossing over the elephant in the room.

We’ve seen times before when things resembled a sinking ship at Michael Andretti’s team. After winning their third championship in four years in 2007, defending champion Dario Franchitti jumped ship to run stock cars for Chip Ganassi in 2008, amid rumors of discord at Andretti-Green.

The famously close foursome from the early days of the team, were long gone. Bryan Herta had been unceremoniously dumped in favor of Danica Patrick. Dan Wheldon left for Ganassi, after winning the 2005 Indianapolis 500 and the IndyCar championship; and was replaced by Marco Andretti. After Franchitti was replaced by Hideki Mutoh, all that was left from the glory years was Tony Kanaan who was blamed for not being able to lead this new young bunch into the promised land.

In 2008 and 2009, there was a mass exodus of key personnel at Andretti-Green; from key engineering staff to even owners Kim Green and Kevin Savoree. Some described it as a three-ring circus waiting to implode. But things did improve.

In 2010, the team was reorganized under the Andretti Autosport banner, but things were still unstable. Longtime sponsor 7-Eleven left at the end of the season and Tony Kanaan was told he could seek employment elsewhere. Ryan Hunter-Reay was brought on in a temporary race-to-race role, even though he ended up driving in every race. Eventually, Kanaan was replaced by Mike Conway for the 2011 season. Andretti Autosport rebounded in 2012, when Hunter-Reay won the IndyCar championship. Hunter-Reay also won the team’s third Indianapolis 500 in 2014.

But things quickly turned sour this past season. It was a collective head-scratcher when Andretti was among the slowest of the Honda teams early on, even though they had done the development work on the Honda aero kit. The Schmidt and Rahal teams were way ahead of Andretti and even Foyt’s team was slightly quicker than the supposedly heavily funded Andretti team. It raised eyebrows and no one could explain it. Later in the season, the team performance improved with the presence of Justin Wilson. Unfortunately, we all know what happened that fateful day at Pocono this past August.

So the question remains…just why is George Klotz leaving Michael Andretti after fourteen years and going to a team that always seems to be on the cusp of a good season, but always fails to deliver. Does he believe he’s the missing piece? He very well could be. Takuma Sato and Jack Hawksworth have talent.

Foyt’s Technical Director, Don Halliday, is one of the most respected men in the IndyCar paddock for many reasons, among those for salvaging good finishes with very few resources. So it’s not like he’s going into the abyss. Ten years ago, that’s how I would have described AJ Foyt Racing, but not today. Larry Foyt has a level head on his shoulders and has done a good job assembling a very talented crew. Perhaps Klotz is the final piece of the puzzle.

But there is still something that tells me that something is not quite right at Andretti Autosport and that’s why George Klotz is leaving. It just doesn’t quite add up. I’m hoping I’m wrong and that Klotz just needs a change of scenery at this point in his career. An implosion at Andretti Autosport would not be a good thing for this series.

George Phillips

Advertisements

14 Responses to “Are The Wheels Starting To Come Off?”

  1. It has become apparent that there are some issues there, especially when one part of the group is suing another. I would think that if there are financial problems, we would be likely to see a reduction in the number of drivers on the team, not the same or possibly more.

    Anything out there about them reducing the number of drivers?

    Sometimes it can be a healthy thing if teams are doing well enough to steal other teams talent. Maybe that is what is going on here. We can only hope.

    I have often felt, rightly or wrongly, that Andretti is a bit of a counterbalance to Penske and Ganassi when it comes to “guiding” the series and is to a positive side. I would hate to see anything happen to this team.

    I don’t think the Andretti’s will be leaving Indycar racing anytime soon. But we might see a bit of a retrenchment for awhile if there is some financial pressure.

  2. I take his departure from Andretti as both a sign of growth on the part of the Foyt program and as a sign of the weakness of the Andretti team.

    It can’t be good as a sign of overall strength of Indycar that the series is basically supported by 3 (and maybe only 2) race teams. It gives those teams an inordinate amount of control over the series itself. Indycar needs more and stronger teams for long-term health.

  3. hey George. these people and there idea that the end of the world is near.

    they may have trouble at Andretti but the end there isn’t near. last I hearf aj pays pretty good and larry seems to let his people do there jobs that may not be the case at Andretti.

    and so maybe George just wanted a change.

  4. Andretti added the Formula e & a team in that X-Games-like racing series the past year. Fe has to be expensive. I am unsure of the other’s cost, but I can’t imagine it is profitable. If someone were to say Andretti is in financial trouble, I’d believe it.

  5. billytheskink Says:

    There was a time when my alma mater’s football program was struggling mightily and in need of a new coach. We went out and hired a moderately successful coach away from another major conference program, a program that had far more recent success and a larger national profile than ours. Why were we able to do that? Because we paid him very well and gave him the opportunity to move back to the state he grew up in.

    Barring some bombshell announcement regarding Andretti Autosport, I think that’s pretty much what we are seeing here.

  6. I did not even know who George Klotz was. Shows how much I know sometimes I think I have a lot to learn about this series. I have no idea what’s behind the rumors but when I heard Andretti Autosport was being sued by a division of itself I thought that was suspect. That was pretty odd. Now his marketing division has thrown in the towel promoting Milwaukee (and suddenly it’s off the schedule) and are they still a player in Marketing St. Petersberg? Plus their struggles for results this year point to troubled seas. Man last thing the Indycar series needs is trouble at Andretti. I agree something must be up.

    • ASM was not the promoter at St. Petersburg. That’s Green Savoree Racing Promotions, Andretti’s former partners at Andretti-Green Racing. They also promote the races at Toronto and Mid-Ohio. – GP

    • It’s also not “his marketing division”, as ASM no longer exists. It’s effectively a new firm that is controlled by Lopes and Taylor after Michael sold them his interest in what was ASM.

  7. Prior to the season, Rob Edwards replaced Kyle Moyer at Andretti. Perhaps this is just a part of the shakeout of an organization that often follows a change at the top.

  8. George,
    It appears to me there probably is an issue at Andretti Autosport……also you may need to re-examine some of the 3 points you take at face value. The “truth” may be stranger than you think! ; )

  9. No doubt that Andretti is going through a rough time, however, I also think that it is something that can be overcome. Once IndyCar “APPROVES” the Honda areokit package this can get the Honda Teams back on track. Also, the racing business is very incestuous in regards to crew, drivers and sponsors. I don’t think anymore about it than Foyt now has Klotz working there.

  10. typical uneducated person posing as a journalist, AJ’s teams in INDYCAR and others have won plenty since 1979 (season championships too) and fair and square, nit by cheating as other teams do.

    seriously if you are too ignorant to do research, stop writing

    • You are correct that AJ Foyt’s team won a part of the inaugural IRL championship with Scott Sharp in 1996 and again with Kenny Bräck in 1998.

      I never claim to be a journalist. In fact, I usually go to great lengths to point out that I’m not one. Curt Cavin, Robin Miller and Marshall Pruett are all journalists. I’m a blogger.

      As for my ignorance and my being uneducated; take a look at your own punctuation, spelling and grammar. If you are so superior, you should take up your own site. It makes me wonder why you bother to read mine.

      I normally don’t respond publicly in such a negative fashion, but the e-mail address you left when you commented was invalid. Typical. I appreciate your interest in my accuracy and in my site. Thanks for reading. – GP

    • Sherman Nelson Says:

      You have to reach back a way and go to ’79. So, how many races/championships has Foyt won since 1998? April, you are a buffoon.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: