Will AJ Allmendinger Move The Needle?

Much has been made recently of AJ Allmendinger possibly running a few races in the IZOD IndyCar Series for Team Penske this season. There is good reason for that. He is a very well known American driver, who has as much talent interacting with fans as he does driving a car on the track. He has won in Champ Car and Grand Am racing. He also had a golden opportunity come up when Roger Penske parted ways with Kurt Busch in Penske’s NASCAR program at the end of the 2011 season. However, halfway through the season, Allmendinger was suspended for testing positive for a substance on NASCAR’s banned substance list.

There are varying reports on that matter, that I’ll not get into. Suffice it to say that this was not a street drug and that Allmendinger may have actually taken a substance without knowing it was banned. Whatever the case, Allmendinger went through NASCAR’s Road to Recovery program and was reinstated near the end of the season.

It would be incorrect to say that Allmendinger had been experiencing a terrific season at Penske before the suspension. In the seventeen points-paying races he ran for Penske, Allmendinger had three front-row starts, one on the pole at Kansas. He also had a second place finish at Martinsville along with two ninth place finishes. In that seventeen race stretch, he also had six finishes lower than thirtieth. After his suspension, Allmendinger was officially dropped from Penske. Or was he?

Roger Penske seemed to take a personal liking to Allmendinger. He was a guest of the team at the IndyCar finale at Fontana last fall. After it became apparent that Team Penske and Ryan Briscoe had parted ways for 2013, the rumor started spreading that Allmendinger would get a few races in Briscoe’s former seat on a part-time basis.

Although nothing is official, the rumor certainly started looking like fact when Allmendinger joined the team for testing at Sebring last week. There are some scheduling conflicts to resolve, but it appears that Allmendinger will be in the Penske car at Barber and the Indianapolis 500 at the very least. Depending on sponsorship, there could be others.

From what I understand, Allmendinger created quite the buzz at Sebring. Several in attendance report that fans turned out just to see how well Allmendinger would do. Some of them had no idea who any other drivers were, but they knew Allmendinger.

The question is, if Allmendinger returns to open-wheel racing for the first time since 2006 – will it make that much of a difference in fan support of the IZOD IndyCar Series? The answer is a definite “I’m not sure”.

My degree is in marketing, but I never heard the term “move the needle” used until I heard it in a racing conversation about five years ago. The debate at that time was how much Danica Patrick “moved the needle” by bringing awareness to the sport. NASCAR had their best ratings for Sunday’s Daytona 500 in years. Much of that is directly related to the presence of Ms. Patrick. It’s safe to say that she moved the needle.

Although we hard-core fans know all about AJ Allmendinger, I think it’s safe to say that most potential new fans outside of racing have no idea who he is. If they do, it’s a good chance they know his name for the wrong reasons by remembering his testing positive for an illegal substance. While most race fans know who AJ Allmendinger is, practically the whole world knows who Danica Patrick is. Consequently, many of them tuned in to watch NASCAR’s version of a single-file parade, while they followed one of the few drivers on the track they could even name.

AJ Allmendinger has a following, but nothing like Danica’s. His following is comprised mostly of those race fans that remember his five wins in 2006 – his last season spent in Champ Car. Then there are those who remember the impressive drive he had for Michael Shank Racing in winning the Rolex 24 in 2011. Without Allmendinger’s strong performance, there is a strong possibility that Michael Shank’s car ends up winning that race. Then there are those who followed Allmendinger ever since he joined NASCAR in 2007. Driving for Red Bull, then Richard Petty Motorsports before moving into the Penske ride – Allmendinger did not attain the same level of success in Cup racing, but he was great with fans and built a loyal following.

Now that he is rumored to drive a handful of races in the IZOD IndyCar Series for Team Penske, some are talking like he is destined to be the savior for the series. Hardly. With all due respect to AJ Allmendinger, it’s going to take a lot more than him to turn around the fortunes of a series desperate for star power and name recognition.

But it certainly can’t hurt. While the presence of AJ Allmendinger may not move the proverbial needle much at first, he has the potential to bring some new eyeballs to our sport. If the new Gen-6 car in NASCAR is no racier in subsequent races than it was in Daytona, fans following Allmendinger may like what they see in the DW12 and how racy it is. Those fans may tell other fans and…well, you get the idea.

That’s the way you build a loyal following – one fan at a time. It may take longer, but the fans you earn that way are much more likely to stay than those casual fans tuning in just to check out the latest craze. If new fans tuned into Daytona because of Danica and experienced racing for the first time, I’ll promise they scratched their heads wondering why all the fuss over auto racing after watching what was a single-file parade for most of the race. They are the ones who question what the big deal is to watch cars go around in a circle. As I watched Sunday’s race, I occasionally asked myself the same thing.

So will AJ Allmendinger move the needle for IndyCar? Not immediately, but if everything plays out over time – he could make a difference. Time will tell.

George Phillips


11 Responses to “Will AJ Allmendinger Move The Needle?”

  1. Bent Wickerbill Says:

    I really like AJA and have followed him since 2006…. He is definitely a positive for the series, but will likely not move the needle a great deal, but whom or what could….? I also agree regarding the circular motion for the 500, however, since they made the cars less adaptable to bump drafting, that is typical plate / pack racing… Not that I am a big fan, but you may see a somewhat racier Gen VI car on non-plate race tracks…

  2. I am all for Dinger and wish him success with his recovery AND career, but as for him “moving the needle,” well, that isn’t going to happen. I doubt that he adds one more fan outside of his kin. Hornish coming back would be a bigger deal.

  3. I think this is a lot more complex issue than people think. I believe that there may be NASCAR fans who liked AJA who might turn on INDYCAR races to see what he does.

    On the other hand-or at least one of the other hands-the reactions that I have seen sound more like desperation than reality. It seems like some INDYCAR fans really want and hope that Allmendinger will make the sport more popular. However, if Allmendinger were so popular, then why weren’t Champ Car’s ratings better than they were? I believe that those who want to believe that Allmendinger’s racing in INDYCAR will “move the needle” are well-intentioned and want to see the series succeed, as I do. However, until seismic changes occur in the mindset of the INDYCAR fanbase, I doubt that Allmendinger’s presence in a few races will really make that much of a difference, sadly. I also don’t think Hornish’s return would be much of a factor either, even if he wanted to come back-and he’s made it clear he’s not returning to INDYCAR anytime soon.

    • hornish returning to Indycar would matter only to the people who remember hornish as an open-wheel driver. those people are already watching Indycar.

  4. there are plenty of Nascar drivers who would move the needle immediately–Stewart, Johnson, Gordon, Junior, Kyle Busch, Harvick, Kenseth, Kayne–but AJ isn’t one of them. and the storyline–if AJ drives and is successful–will be how a lower-tier Nascar driver dominates in Indycar.

  5. Possibly. If he started dating Ricky Stenhouse Jr.

  6. billytheskink Says:

    I’m 99% sure of two things:
    1. Allmendinger won’t move the needle in the wrong direction, and
    2. Using the phrase “move the needle” when referring to a guy who recently failed a drug test makes me feel kinda awkward.

    I was big fan of AJ’s when he ran in ChampCar and in NASCAR (and I’ve got the RuSport and Hunt Bros. Pizza t-shirts to prove it), so I’m excited about the possibility of him racing Indycars this year. But beyond that, I almost always think it is interesting whenever racers switch disciplines, and Allmendinger should intrigue the handful of folks who think the same way. It’s a start.

  7. hadrianmarcus Says:

    Will AJ’s return move the needle, probably not. But he is a talented driver…and American. It would be refreshing for the Indycar to have a number of talented American drivers. This situation tells me a lot about Roger Penske. When both AJ and Helio faced some difficult times, Penske stayed loyal to some degree. The man is a firm good judge of talent and I suspect AJ will return to racing all the more humble, wiser and a lot more appreciative.

  8. I pondered this question relative to Baricello on twitter a few days ago.

    I doubt AJ brings new eyeballs to the 500. But if casual nascar fans happen to turn into the 500, a familiar name might keep their interest.

  9. This thing with Almendinger is “Will Power” all over again. Penske will replace Helio after this year with Dinger in the future. These races will be a testing of Dinger, with positive results, he will slide right into Helio’s ride.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: