The Beleaguered No. 10

When Dario Franchitti took over the reins of the No. 10 Target car, he became Scott Dixon’s eighth teammate since Target Chip Ganassi racing moved over to the IRL from CART in 2003. All but one of those eight were assigned to the No. 10 machine. The other was Ryan Briscoe who, as a rookie, drove a third full-time No. 33 Target entry.

The short history of the No. 10 car has been star-crossed, to say the least. Tomas Scheckter had shown so much promise as a rookie. Surely Ganassi could do a much better job of harnessing that talent within Scheckter than his former employer; Eddie Cheever – himself a Ganassi castoff from earlier times. The Scheckter and Ganassi marriage didn’t last long, however. The results weren’t that bad really, as Scheckter finished seventh in the standings – although his teammate Scott Dixon won the championship. But as he has been known to do, Scheckter wore out his welcome early and was given his walking papers at the end of the season.

Promising newcomer Tony Renna was hired to replace Scheckter in the No. 10, alongside Dixon. Unfortunately, it never came to pass. On a cold October morning after the 2003 season had ended, the team was testing at Indianapolis with Renna at the wheel. On only his fourth lap, Renna spun in turn three. His car went airborne and flew into the catch fence in the north short chute. Renna’s car split apart and he was fatally injured. In fact, Renna is the last driver fatality at the Speedway. If there is a silver lining to such an incident, it is that there were no spectators on hand as parts of the car actually flew into the stands. The result of the Renna crash and the Kenny Bräck crash which occurred a few weeks earlier at Texas, was the introduction of the longitudinal wickers running the entire length of the car in an attempt to keep cars from going airborne as they skid sideways.

After Tony Renna’s death – Ganassi turned to Darren Manning, who had driven in CART for Derrick Walker, for the 2004 season. Saddled with a suddenly uncompetitive Toyota engine, the Ganassi team struggled. Manning finished eleventh in the points for 2004 with a best finish of fourth – three times at Motegi, Nashville and Pikes Peak. He was released halfway through the season in 2005 immediately following the Milwaukee race in late July. His best finish for 2005 had been a sixth at the season opener at Homestead. His seat was filled with substitute runs by Jaques Lazier and little know Italian driver Giorgio Pantano.

For 2006, Ganassi seemingly solved the problem of the beleaguered No. 10 car by signing Dan Wheldon fresh off of his Indy winning and championship season of 2005. It appeared to be a stroke of genius as Wheldon won his first race out of the gate with his new team at Homestead. Wheldon led early on at Indy that year and lost the championship to Sam Hornish on a tiebreaker. By all indications, Target Chip Ganassi had found a new team leader in the flamboyant Wheldon. Dixon had come off of two disappointing seasons that saw him finish thirteenth in the final 2005 standings. Now that Ganassi had the same Honda engine as everyone, Dixon’s performance improved. But Dixon’s demeanor kept him out of the spotlight while Wheldon grabbed the headlines every chance he got. There were rumblings toward the end of 2006 that Dixon may be the odd man out at Ganassi, even as he finished a respectable fourth for 2006.

But the luck of the No. 10 eventually took over. Wheldon’s 2007 season started strong – collecting two wins and a second in the first four races. Beyond that though, the best he could muster were three third place finishes along with four DNF’s. Meanwhile, Dixon continued to show steady improvement as he lost the 2007 championship when his car hiccupped on the last turn of the last lap of the last race. He finished second to Andretti-Green’s Dario Franchitti, who bolted for NASCAR for the 2008 season. Dixon went on to win his second championship in 2008 while Wheldon continued with inconsistency. After the Nashville race, it was reported that he and Ganassi had agreed on a new contract. A month later, it was announced he would leave the team after Ganassi had offered the seat to his former friend and teammate Tony Kanaan.

Enter Nashville resident Dario Franchitti, who had signed to drive for Ganassi in his ill-fated attempt at NASCAR. Franchitti replaced Wheldon in the No. 10 for 2009 and has had a very successful season. Like his teammate, he has won four races. Also like his teammate, he has led the points standings a couple of times this season. He currently sits five points behind Dixon for the season championship.

Time will tell if the curse of the No. 10 car has been lifted. Franchitti is one of three drivers, along with Dixon and Briscoe, still alive for the 2009 championship. The other two teams have won championships before, but not the No 10 team. No matter what kind of season Franchitti has produced this year, the No. 10 team will need to win a championship before they can be viewed as being equal to the No 9 team, of Dixon. Franchitti looks as if he can stay in that car until he decides it’s time to hang up his helmet. He has already won a championship albeit with another team.

But Franchitti will need to win a championship for this current team as well. Otherwise, history will treat the No. 10 team as Ganassi’s second-string outfit. Fair or not, that’s what will happen. Franchitti has an excellent shot to bring a championship trophy to the No. 10 team so that they can have one of their own to go alongside the two that Dixon brought home as well as the four CART trophies that Jimmy Vasser, Alex Zanardi and Juan Montoya won for Ganassi in consecutive years.

Franchitti himself has nothing else to prove. But until the No 10 team can win a championship of their own, they will continue to be viewed as a star-crossed team.

George Phillips


10 Responses to “The Beleaguered No. 10”

  1. As opposed to the No. 10 car, could it just be an issue with the No. 10 team? I wonder if that group fall short in terms of setting the car up and strategic thinking..?

  2. Tim Nothhelfer Says:

    I was hopeful for Dan to win another championship at TGN.
    Now I am hopeful he will contend for another win at Panther.
    Until another team elevates itself substantially, it is a long step down from one of the red cars!

  3. Slightly off-topic George, but regarding your recent post about Team 3G/Greg Beck, what do you make of the recent situation with Leilani Münter and the faltering Team 3G IndyLights team?

    (Link here if you haven’t read it:

  4. This season the driver and crew of the ’10 car,’ on the tenth day of the tenth month of the year has won a tenth race for Ganassi Racing plus the championship. Guess the number’s not important. Thanks for your wonderful weblog posts.

  5. Andrew Bernstein Says:

    “…as parts of the car actually flew into the stands.”

    Care to quote a source for this statement, please?

    • oilpressure Says:

      Right off the top of my head, I recall reading this account in Dr. Steve Olvey’s book Rapid Response. He wasn’t present, but gave a fairly accountable description in his book. I also recall articles from the IndyStar giving descriptiuons as well. I’m not a journalist, but unless I’m inserting my opinion – I try to stick to facts in my articles. While sitting in my office at work, I cannot access other sources at the moment but give me time and I’ll produce more if you like. – GP

  6. Andrew Bernstein Says:

    Thank you Gentlemen,

    The Cavin article is one I had not found. The investigations and subsequent regulation changes of ’04 are my point of interest, as the lift factor is the greatest determinant in the current downforce configuration. This will also be priority number one in the formulation of a new chassis design, in my opinion.

    I have found some of Mr. Barnhart’s quoted summaries of the reports, but none of the in-house or independant analysis. If there are any additional resources you can provide about these studies, I would greatly appreciate it.

    Sad to be looking beyond the passing of a fine young man, and I hope I have not created that impression.

    RIP, Tony

    Andrew Bernstein

  7. Brian McKay Says:

    Now the #10 team and its driver have won the Indy 500 after winning last season’s championship.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: