Random Thoughts On Iowa

geothumbnail10
Although the weather looked ominous just a few hours earlier, yesterday’s Iowa Corn 250 at Iowa Speedway came off without a hitch. Helio Castroneves won the third heat race on Saturday, which meant that he would start on the pole. However, he incurred a ten- grid-spot penalty for an unapproved engine change. Fortunately for Helio, he was able to keep the nine points that came with winning the heat race. That put his teammate, Will Power, on the pole to start the race with James Hinchcliffe on the outside of the front row. That was about as close to glory as Will Power would come. By the end of the first lap, James Hinchcliffe was in the lead and he never looked back.

Yes Hinchcliffe dominated the race, but that doesn’t mean it was boring – far from it. Although the leader pretty much remained static throughout the race, except for pit stop re-shuffling – there was all kinds of action going on behind the leader.

Ryan Hunter-Reay had the drive of the day. He made a mistake early, when he clipped the rear wheel of Graham Rahal and had to change his front wing. That put him back to twenty-first and the last car on the lead lap. But he showed his grit by carving his way up through the field and showing everyone that he isn’t satisfied with just one championship. Hunter-Reay finished second, and had he not been boxed in by three backmarkers late in the race, he could have made a serious challenge for the win. As it was, he salvaged a ton of points and took advantage of a so-so day by Helio Castroneves. Hunter-Reay now trails Helio in the points standings by those nine points Helio got for winning the third heat race on Saturday.

Tony Kanaan had a spirited battle with Graham Rahal for third. Kanaan had pitted earlier and had fresh tires. That proved to be the difference as Rahal’s tires started going away. He lost third to Kanaan and eventually lost fourth to Ed Carpenter. Still, after I questioned his desire on Wednesday – give Rahal credit for showing up very racy this past weekend.

It was another clean race. A few drivers brushed the wall, and Alex Tagliani spun bringing out a yellow – but there was no actual carnage. In fact, we haven’t seen any significant damage to any cars since the melee that took place during the second race at the Belle Isle double-header. Not only is that good because no drivers were put in peril, but it also means that the teams made it though this stint of six races in five weeks without repairing a lot of crashed race cars. That means SportsCenter had little to show what their definition of racing action was, but it’s always good when crashes are held to a minimum.

TV Coverage: First of all, I found the pre-race segment where Eddie Cheever and Scott Goodyear assigned mid-season grades to teams to be a little awkward. Neither of them seemed comfortable in their roles. I think John McLallen and I are more relaxed on our “One Take Only” spots than these two were. Maybe I missed it, but what was the deal with the Fan’s Poll on the far right of the screen? Who was polled and when did this happen? Perhaps I had a brain-fade and they explained this source, but I never heard it. Why have it up there if you’re not even going to explain it.

On the plus side, I thought that ABC’s coverage for Sunday’s race was an improvement over what they gave us two weeks ago in Texas. But I’ve also resigned myself that with this announcing crew in the booth, we will never get what NBCSN gave us at Milwaukee. It simply boils down to chemistry, or lack thereof. I still contend that Scott Goodyear is not the problem. He simply plays up or down to whomever he is paired with. If it were up to me (which thankfully, for everyone, it is not) I would keep Goodyear and let the other two go. I’ve piled on Marty Reid enough that to do more is pointless. To me, the biggest disappointment is Eddie Cheever.

I keep going back to that race at Texas in 1998. Cheever was an early out, and he was asked to come join Paul Page in the booth. He did and he was hilarious. He offered fresh insight with a sharp sense of humor. We all knew at some point he would be in the booth calling races. It came to fruition ten years later in 2008 for the Indianapolis 500 coverage only, but has been a massive disappointment. The new Eddie Cheever comes across as a monotone stuffed shirt with no sense of humor. A “bump on a log” comes to mind when describing what Cheever brings to the broadcast. His first year, I chalked it up to nerves – but it didn’t improve. When they announced that for this season, he would join Reid and Goodyear for the entire season; I thought that this was a chance for the team to build some chemistry. It hasn’t happened. As we approach their season farewell with one race to go in two weeks – I can only hope that this is a permanent farewell to this broadcasting team.

If I were the only one saying this, it might be written off as me being tough to please or having some sort of agenda. But that isn’t the case. In fact, I’m not sure that this current ABC/ESPN announcing team has any supporters. The best thing I read here and elsewhere is that some people don’t think they are too bad. If that’s the best that can be said – there are problems. Enough said.

Speaking of awkward: Maybe it’s just me, but I found it just a tad bit awkward that the National Guard is still running the commercial with JR Hildebrand in his Panther Racing driving suit. I understand that this was an effective spot and the cost was probably significant. But since he is no longer with Panther Racing, it just seemed a little odd. I’m sure that Hildebrand is just as committed to the National Guard as ever, but to use his likeness in a Panther Racing uniform seemed just a little distracting.

Back to reality: While many teams and drivers are enjoying breakout seasons, one team that found success earlier is now falling back to the pack – and the grips of reality. It’s now like a distant memory that Takuma Sato and AJ Foyt Enterprises were leading the points through the Month of May. Sato won at Long Beach and came within one turn and a few blocks of winning at Brazil. Since then, Sato has finishes of thirteenth, nineteenth, twenty-third, eleventh, seventh and twenty-third. As a consequence, Sato has slipped from leading the points just a month ago to currently sitting in eighth.

Most know that I am a Team Penske fan. I also currently pull for KV Racing Technology because that’s where Tony Kanaan drives. But my sentimental favorite has always been the team of AJ Foyt. After so many lean years at this fabled team, it was good to see them on top. Now I wonder if what we saw from Sato and Larry Foyt was an anomaly. The season is half over. Which results are we going to see from AJ Foyt Enterprises? The one that was smart and aggressive in making all the right moves, or the one that shows up with ill-prepared cars, questionable pits stops and strategy as well as driver mistakes? I’m really not sure, but as a fan of this team, I feel like a Cubs fan that has seen their team close out April in first place. You know it isn’t for real.

Too many yellows: Now, I’m not talking about there being too many caution periods in Sunday’s race. In fact, there were only three for twenty-nine laps – making it a very clean race.

No, I’m talking about the actual number of yellow cars in this race. It used to be that if your driver was in a bright yellow car, it was very easy to pick him or her out – whether at the track or from your couch. This race had five cars with predominantly yellow paint schemes – three were in the top five. Several years ago, black was the hot color. Then around 2005, it seemed that everyone had a blue & white car. Now it’s yellow. I know teams have to go with what the sponsor wants, but it seems strange that this year (this week especially) so many are yellow.

Credit Hunter-Reay: Not only did Ryan Hunter-Reay have the drive of the day to go from twenty-first to second, but he also had the class move of the day.

When he was explaining to his team what had happened when he clipped Graham Rahal’s left rear, he could have just as easily laid some or all of the blame on Rahal. Instead, he owned up and said he simply made a mistake and misjudged his move.

There was a time a few years ago, when Hunter-Reay would have tried to point the finger of blame on another driver. But this version of Ryan Hunter-Reay is more secure and confident in his driving ability and his status among his fellow drivers. In short, he is not driving for his job. I’d say his employment is fairly secure and he doesn’t feel the need to randomly blame other drivers for his mistakes. Other drivers could take a cue from RHR.

The championship battle: Speaking of Ryan Hunter-Reay, I continue to think that this championship is his for the taking. He didn’t win this race like he did last year, but he came pretty close. None of the other points leaders act like they want to stay there, including the current one. Personally, I’m pulling for Helio to finally win his first championship –but he needs to drive more like he wants it.

Helio has held the lead for the longest, but it seems very tenuous. Hunter-Reay is driving like he wants it. He is being consistently fast and smart. Most importantly, when he does make a mistake like he did Sunday, he is able to put it behind him and forget about it. Don’t be surprised if he is hoisting the Astor-Challenge Cup again at the end of this season.

All in all: I thought this was a very good race. What it lacked in drama up front, it certainly made up for behind the leader. James Hinchcliffe is having an unbelievable season. It’s easy to forget that he was winless coming into this season. Now he leads all drivers this season with three victories. The odd thing is how hot & cold his season has been. His three wins are offset by finishes of twenty-sixth, twenty-sixth, twenty-first and nineteenth. Finally at Texas and Milwaukee he was able to string together a pair of top-ten finishes without winning. That’s what it takes to win a championship. With his win on Sunday, Hinchcliffe jumped to fourth in the overall standings.

But there was no question who the class of the field was on Sunday. Michael Andretti’s team has now won five of the seven races at Iowa, with Hinchcliffe being the latest to benefit from this team’s setup. They are obviously doing something right.

Pure race fans enjoyed this race on Sunday. Those that complained that only ten cars remained on the lead lap, there weren’t any spectacular crashes and that the same driver led all but twenty-three laps don’t understand how to appreciate good racing. There is so much more to this sport than swapping the lead while running side-by-side. This race was a case study in what to appreciate about open-wheel racing.

George Phillips

About these ads

17 Responses to “Random Thoughts On Iowa”

  1. Sorry, but I have to disagree about the ABC coverage. It’s a busy track and there IS a lot of stuff going on all around it, so I can see where a director can have a hard time choosing which camera to go live with at any given moment. That being said, I can’t count how many on-track passes were occurring between drivers near the front, all seeming contenders (before Hinch’s domination-to-be was known) for the win, that weren’t shown because they cut away to some other action back in the middle of the pack. I’m not an “only show the front cars” guy, but when you see one shaping up between the cars running second and third, or fourth and fifth, stay with it. That may be telling in the outcome of the race, and they skipped away from a number of those moments.

    • That’s why I didn’t gripe about what the director was covering. ABC did a good job in following the racing behind the leader. My complaint was strictly about the chemistry (or lack thereof) between the broadcast crew. And by the way…the pit reporters did an excellent job yesterday. I forgot to mention them.

    • Mike,
      Glad you said that. I noticed it too. Camera on Rahal and Kanaan fighting for position, cut to show Franchitti green flag pit stop (4 laps down). WTF? Also, did anyone else notice that ABC didn’t run the pit stop timer during the Green Flag stops (when it really matters) but instead ran it on the Yellow Flag stops? Have these clowns ever produced an automobile race before, or is this the production crew from ESPN’s girl’s softball?

    • Gurney Eagle Says:

      I must admit that I thought Reid did a good job yesterday. He seemed to show more enthusiasm than usual and he did a better job than I did in identifying which yellow car was which.

  2. Good review George. Hinch and his Go Daddy team ran aa almost perfect race.The front left tire mishap in the pits put a scare in me, but the car and the mayor were flawless. Hinch and RHR are the new stars of the series and I am enjoying watching their careers unfold.

  3. OK, got my ABC rant out of the way. Sorry, I promised after last year I was done complaining about ABC because it was obviously never going to change.

    Great race. I wish I was there. Iowa is an awesome track for watching a race, and the Indycar product seems perfectly suited to this little bull ring in the corn fields. More please Mr. Miles.

  4. I have an idea to save some production money for ABC. Run the crawl across the top of the screen so we can see the running order. Then have an intern monitor all the driver/pit radio communications and switch to whichever conversation is the most interesting at the time. That way they can save money on announcer salaries.

  5. Also: Nascar called. They didn’t realize the “highly marketable Canadian” could drive ovals too. They said keep Rahal, but we’ll take that kid and some more of Go-Daddy’s money.

  6. Disagree on ABC criticism in general and Cheever in particular. I thought ABC was solid all day — yeah, they screwed up here and there, but the bulk of the day they were following the battles very well. Per Cheever: I was no fan of his early on because he seemed pretty arrogant. But these days he seems to give me pertinent information at just the right time. I don’t want a booth crew who is screaming how EXCITING everything is, just one that gives me info at the right time that helps me enjoy the race more. Eddie in particular did that several times at Iowa. I also think the Eddie/Goodyear chemistry is developing pretty well.

  7. I think Hinch would make a great announcer. He was so good yestaerday I feel he could have called the race and still won it. This Championship is Andretti’s to lose, and I don’t mean Marco.

  8. billytheskink Says:

    I gotta agree with Pressdog and Gurney, I thought this was far and away the ABC team’s best performance this year. Reid seemed prepared and both Goodyear and Cheever actually raised their voices a few times in excitement. Also, big kudos to them for confusing Rahal and Franchitti’s cars far less often than I did.

    On that subject, first we had Franchitti driving a Hinchcliffe doppelganger at Texas, and now a Rahal imitator at Iowa. Why are Target’s vendors working so hard to confuse us?

    George, could you please write about Rahal on the Wednesday before each of this season’s remaining races?
    Seriously though, it was good to see Graham competitive again, even though he pushed his tires too hard trying to catch Hinchcliffe on that final stint. It’s worth noting that he made the only non-pit stop-aided pass for the lead yesterday, nipping Hinch at the line after the final restart to lead lap 160.

  9. Ron Ford Says:

    A very enjoyable race. I agree with Pdog, Gurney, and the Skinkster regarding the ABC coverage. I was fine with it. No artificial excitement necessary. What I did think was terrible once again was the Mike King, Davey Hamilton streaming fiasco for the heat races. I don’t know what the problem is there, but what they were talking about was seldom, if ever, related to what was being shown on the track.

  10. Could not disagree more about ABC. They pale in comparison (not that anyone is making a direct comparison) to NBCSports.

    Indycar needs the excitement, “artificially” produced or not. While the last few oval races have been well-driven, low yellow, non-crashing events that are interesting for what we like to call the “die-hard fan,” they don’t seem to be bringing new fans to the arena.

    Indycar needs to produce more excitement–from driver marketing to speeds to car design to entertainment to announcers that seem a bit less lethargic. I know this may not be in the interest of “pure racing” for the knowledgeable fans, but–and I know George will not like this statement–in order to grow they have to increase the entertainment aspect of the sport. Because it’s not just sport anymore, it’s entertainment.

  11. As if it was even possible, Mousy Marty did not seem prepared at all. Less prepared than usual. It’s like he pays no attention to the off-track affairs of the sport inbetween ABC races, and reads the teleprompter like the current Predisent. Remember “Pat”, Amy’s mother on “Everybody Loves Raymond”? She had this, “Oh, my!” demeanor. That’s Marty Ried when he sees on-track action. Paul Page had an, “Oh, yeah!” attitude about it; he got excited because he actually gives more than a fart in a whirlwind about IndyCar racing.

    I could do a better job than Mousy Marty. Easliy.

  12. Ballyhoo Says:

    I think I have said more than enough lately on ABC. One more race, thank you. It was a good gesture to cover the heat races from Saturday in Iowa during Sunday’s broadcast, but I would have watched qualifying live on ABC if it had been offered. I am looking forward to having qualifying back on the broadcast in Toronto.

    I think our critiques of Graham paid off. He looked good and didn’t complain as much as usual after the race. RHR is the man to beat this season!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 106 other followers

%d bloggers like this: